Here's a look at the best picks from the past 10 years for each MLB club, showcasing the talent that has been drafted and developed into future stars. From MVP candidates to Cy Young winners, these players have made their mark in the league. Here's a breakdown of the top picks from each team, with commentary on their impact and potential.
AL East
Blue Jays: Bo Bichette (2016, 2nd round)
Bo Bichette, a potential plus-plus hitter, has been a steady performer for the Blue Jays. With a .290 average and 29 homers in 2021, he's shown power and consistency. His three-year, $126 million deal is a testament to his value.
Orioles: Gunnar Henderson (2019, 2nd round)
Gunnar Henderson has topped Adley Rutschman in career bWAR and wRC+, showcasing his defensive skills and offensive impact. His performance has been a bright spot for the Orioles.
Rays: Joe Ryan (2018, 7th round)
Joe Ryan, a Cape Cod League All-Star, has become a two-time All-Star for the Twins. His 13.8 bWAR is impressive, especially considering his 7th-round draft position.
Red Sox: Roman Anthony (2022, supplemental 2nd round)
Roman Anthony, once seen as a power-over-hit guy, has become a potential superstar. His .292/.396/.463 rookie season and three-year, $126 million deal are a testament to his talent.
Yankees: Cam Schlittler (2022, 7th round)
Cam Schlittler, a postseason hero and All-Star, has dominated with a 2.01 ERA and 131 strikeouts. His performance has been a steal for the Yankees.
AL Central
Guardians: Shane Bieber (2016, 4th round)
Shane Bieber's control and velocity improvements have led to All-Star nods and an AL Cy Young Award. His performance has been a bright spot for the Guardians.
Royals: Bobby Witt Jr. (2019, 1st round)
Bobby Witt Jr. has become the face of the franchise, signing an 11-year, $288.8 million contract extension. His power and speed make him a top talent.
Tigers: Tarik Skubal (2018, 9th round)
Tarik Skubal has dominated as a lefty, winning back-to-back AL Cy Young Awards. His performance has made him a free-agent market favorite.
Twins: Brent Rooker (2017, supplemental 1st round)
Brent Rooker has found success with the A's, making the All-Star team and winning a Silver Slugger Award.
White Sox: Garrett Crochet (2020, 1st round)
Garrett Crochet's performance has been a bright spot for the White Sox, making two All-Star Games and leading the AL with 255 strikeouts.
AL West
Angels: Zach Neto (2022, 1st round)
Zach Neto has been a steady performer, with back-to-back 5+ WAR seasons and 49 homers in two seasons.
Astros: Jeremy Peña (2018, 3rd round)
Jeremy Peña has become a defensive shortstop and offensive impact player, winning a Gold Glove and Championship Series MVP.
A's: Nick Kurtz (2024, 1st round)
Nick Kurtz has taken home Rookie of the Year and Silver Slugger Awards, with 36 homers in his rookie season.
Mariners: Cal Raleigh (2018, 3rd round)
Cal Raleigh has been an All-Star and Silver Slugger Award winner, with 60 homers and 100+ RBI in three seasons.
Rangers: Wyatt Langford (2023, 1st round)
Wyatt Langford has shown promise with the Rangers, batting .251/.333/.434 with 46 homers and 47 steals in 308 games.
NL East
Braves: Michael Harris II (2019, 3rd round)
Michael Harris II has become an NL Rookie of the Year and a 20-20 season performer, showcasing his offensive and defensive skills.
Marlins: Michael King (2016, 12th round)
Michael King, a former reliever, has become a quality starter, exceeding expectations with the Padres.
Mets: Pete Crow-Armstrong (2020, 1st round)
Pete Crow-Armstrong has blossomed into a superstar, with elite defense and power. His performance could make him a perennial MVP candidate.
Nationals: Jesús Luzardo (2016, 3rd round)
Jesús Luzardo has been a stable rotation option, finishing 7th in NL Cy Young voting and making his first All-Star game.
Phillies: Bryson Stott (2019, 1st round)
Bryson Stott has been a consistent performer, with double-digit homers and 24 or more steals in each of his four seasons.
NL Central
Brewers: Jacob Misiorowski (2022, 2nd round)
Jacob Misiorowski has become a certified ace, with a high fastball and improving control. He could win his first NL Cy Young this year.
Cardinals: JJ Wetherholt (2024, 1st round)
JJ Wetherholt has started his career as an all-around above-average hitter and one of the best defensive second basemen.
Cubs: Nico Hoerner (2018, 1st round)
Nico Hoerner has been a reliable hitter with gap power and basestealing savvy, winning two Gold Gloves.
Pirates: Paul Skenes (2023, 1st round)
Paul Skenes has dominated as a pitcher, winning Rookie of the Year and Cy Young Award in 2025.
Reds: Andrew Abbott (2021, 2nd round)
Andrew Abbott has led his draft class with 13.4 WAR, earning All-Star recognition and Cy Young votes.
NL West
D-backs: Corbin Carroll (2019, 1st round)
Corbin Carroll has become an NL Rookie of the Year and a dynamic player, with a 30-30 season in 2025.
Dodgers: Will Smith (2016, 1st round)
Will Smith has starred for the Dodgers, winning three World Series and three straight All-Star Games.
Giants: Bryan Reynolds (2016, 2nd round)
Bryan Reynolds has been a best position player for the Pirates, gaining All-Star recognition.
Padres: James Wood (2021, 2nd round)
James Wood has become a power hitter, with high exit velocities and barrel rates.
Rockies: Hunter Goodman (2021, 4th round)
Hunter Goodman has shown power potential, with 31 homers in 2025 and an All-Star appearance.
